In music, when someone learns to play an instrument, it’s very important to learn what the proper position for the hands is (When playing the piano, for example, your wrist is not supposed to be very low or very high; the fingers should be bent and not straight, etc…) You can play easy pieces even if your hands are not set up correctly, but as the music becomes harder, it’ll be hard and then impossible to play fluently. Professional music teachers are very critical of “amateurs” who don’t pay attention to hand position when they teach the beginners. It turns out that it’s very hard, next to impossible, even for children, to unlearn.
Something very similar happens when learning mathematics, I think. Sometimes I want to ask my students to forget all math they have “learned” before. It seems to be easier to teach them “from scratch” than to correct the misconceptions they have.
The biggest misconception of all is that mathematics is learned by memorization. (I know I am not saying anything new here.) A student told me once that I am the first instructor who told them that they have to understand the material, not to memorize it. Really. (To be fair to my CUNY colleagues, that happened when I was an adjunct somewhere else.) Students are surprised when I tell them that the multiplication tables are probably the first and the last thing I learned by rote, memorized purposefully, rather than “accidentally”. “Accidentally”, of course, is not a good word here. I didn’t memorize the Pythagorean Theorem by accident; I memorized it because I used it a lot.
It is a wellknown problem of the secondary school curriculum (and our Algebra courses, yes) – being a mile wide and an inch deep. Students don’t get a chance to master the material before moving on to something new. Why, oh why did my daughter have to start learning statistics in Kindergarten? (No kidding. Everyday Mathematics curriculum in action here…) I would prefer her to do more addition/subtraction word problems in order to learn (yes, to learn, not to memorize per se) the “number facts”, rather than draw boxes for histograms.
Since the students don’t have enough practice to learn by doing, they are encouraged to memorize things. Memorization of the facts and formulas does not cause too much harm, though. Much worse is the memorization of concepts, which also seems to be encouraged. Students are instructed, for example, to use addition or multiplication when they see the word “more” in a word problem, and subtraction or division when they see the word “less”. “More” and “less” are the concepts, and they can mean different things in different situations. Look for example at the following problem, fresh from this year’s 4th grade test:
Twenty eight students attended the first meeting of the club. Four times more students attended the first meeting than the second meeting. How many students attended the second meeting?
It is a multiplechoice problem, and 7 and 112 are among the answer choices, of course. So what do the welltrained students do when they see the word “more”? They are prepped to recognize the word, not to think what it means for each particular problem. Under the pressure of the moment, who would think about which meeting really had more students in attendance? “More” means multiply, period.
On the other hand, may be the issue here is not memorization, or even mathematics in general. Could it be that children are having a problem processing the language here, and their trouble is not really of the “mathematical” kind? Elementary school teachers are teaching their students language skills, too, so they are supposed to be able to prepare them both to understand the problem and to do the calculations.
I, a college math instructor, am another story, though. I think it is a good problem. It is formulated that cumbersomely on purpose, obviously, but it’s OK, the students should be doing some thinking, too, not just mindless calculations. Unfortunately, this problem is not very different from the ones we ask our Algebra students to be able to solve. They also know that “more” means to multiply. I can tell them a million times to read the problem carefully, but if they don’t understand that “more” “belongs” to the first meeting, not the second, what do I do? Suddenly it is me who has to teach them the language processing skills. What’s more, I realize that many of my students don’t even know what it means to UNDERSTAND. They really think it is the same as to remember! How do I teach them to internalize, to absorb, to make their own? Isn’t it something we learn little by little since we are infants? How do I teach that to adults? I just don’t know.
About the Blog
Click here for information about the CUNYMath Blog  what it's for, who made it, how to become a Featured Author, how to type math on the blog, and more.
Click here to learn about the header image, which depicts the Cairo Tessellation.
Subscribe

Recent Posts

Authors
Recent Comments
 pinoy flix on CUNY students: Paid tutors needed for spring semester! Apply by December 16!
 Pinoy Lambingan on CUNY students: Paid tutors needed for spring semester! Apply by December 16!
 masoncarter on CUNY’s Algebra for All application: open now for NYC DOE Teachers!
 WhatsApp on Math You Use?
 WhatsApp Gold on Math You Use?
Archives
 January 2021
 October 2020
 August 2020
 May 2020
 March 2020
 November 2019
 March 2019
 November 2018
 September 2018
 July 2018
 June 2018
 March 2018
 November 2017
 July 2017
 June 2017
 May 2017
 April 2017
 March 2017
 February 2017
 September 2016
 June 2016
 May 2016
 November 2015
 May 2015
 April 2015
 February 2015
 November 2014
 September 2014
 August 2014
 June 2014
 February 2014
 August 2013
 July 2013
 May 2013
 April 2013
 February 2013
 January 2013
 November 2012
 October 2012
 September 2012
 August 2012
 July 2012
 June 2012
 May 2012
 April 2012
 March 2012
 February 2012
Categories
Great article! That kind of information is shared on the internet. Come and consult with my website. Thank you
Hello friends, pleasant paragraph and nice arguments commented at this place, I am actually enjoying by these.
I hope teachers think more about the usage of UNDERSTANDING and MEMORIZING. It will help children (and adults) a lot!
Nigeria needs to upgrade our education system worst in the world
and yes, reading carefully is also important. blame it on my age or on the time we live in… but I feel that people seem
Thanks for this description of and context for your interesting research project. I am eager to read subsequent
Education here is south africa need upgrading also
It’s going to be ending of mine day, except before finish I am reading this enormous piece of writing to improve my knowhow.
Dear Asya,
Thank you for your thoughts. Really good to see you write on understanding rather than just memorizing. When I look at children here in The Netherlands, lots of time is spend on drilling the multiplication tables instead of learning the ideas/concept behind it.
Although it is good to use memory when needed, understanding is more powerful. That is what I did when I was studying physics. It saved me lots of time and stress! Understand the concepts and you can apply it in nearly any situation.
When you do have to memorize new information, I would like to suggest people learn the memory techniques which are thousands of years old, but still deliver amazing results.
I hope teachers think more about the usage of UNDERSTANDING and MEMORIZING. It will help children (and adults) a lot!
(and yes, reading carefully is also important. blame it on my age or on the time we live in… but I feel that people seem to need a fast paced life. the first impression is not even processed… but the next one is already searched for. stop, think, evaluate/understand/remember, and then move on)
Thanks for your thoughts!